Out of nowhere, the Hong Kong Government decides they want to donate HKD100 billion of public funds for the rebuilding of Sichuan. There are a few problems that have arisen from this announcement.
Fairness?
Hong Kongers living in poverty, feel that the government has shunned them. This aid was so easily and so quickly offered to Sichuan, while the impoverished have to protest and beg, only to get very little in return. Indeed many Hong Kongers are facing economic difficulties at the moment, and there have been noticeable cases where the government has ignored pleas for help. I'm sure many agree that money should be donated, but they're also asking, "what about me?".
Filtering.
Where will this money go? To Sichuan, of course! Not so fast. China is notorious for its corruption and its lack of clarity. This is afterall the blood and sweat of Hong Kong taxpayers. We want to know that the money is going to the right place and not into the pockets of corrupt officials, or corrupt contractors. This type of skepticism should be a shock to no one. There's nothing wrong with wanting to know how your money is spent. Have a plan. It is foolish to make such an announcement without a plan to reassure people their donation will be put to good use. We don't have a choice whether to give the money or not, so at least try to put our minds at ease.
Surprise!
Where is this sudden enthusiasm from the government coming from? The earthquake occurred in May. Why offer the donation now? There is speculation that Donald Tsang wants to offer this as a gift to vice president, Xi Jinping during his visit to Hong Kong. This is unlikely, but you do have to question the timing of this offering. Why make a move that might raise eyebrows? Use common sense. Try to make it our decision instead of just yours. Again, if the government proposed this donation earlier on, when people were in more of a giving mood, perhaps they wouldn't be met with such resistance.
Fairness?
Hong Kongers living in poverty, feel that the government has shunned them. This aid was so easily and so quickly offered to Sichuan, while the impoverished have to protest and beg, only to get very little in return. Indeed many Hong Kongers are facing economic difficulties at the moment, and there have been noticeable cases where the government has ignored pleas for help. I'm sure many agree that money should be donated, but they're also asking, "what about me?".
Filtering.
Where will this money go? To Sichuan, of course! Not so fast. China is notorious for its corruption and its lack of clarity. This is afterall the blood and sweat of Hong Kong taxpayers. We want to know that the money is going to the right place and not into the pockets of corrupt officials, or corrupt contractors. This type of skepticism should be a shock to no one. There's nothing wrong with wanting to know how your money is spent. Have a plan. It is foolish to make such an announcement without a plan to reassure people their donation will be put to good use. We don't have a choice whether to give the money or not, so at least try to put our minds at ease.
Surprise!
Where is this sudden enthusiasm from the government coming from? The earthquake occurred in May. Why offer the donation now? There is speculation that Donald Tsang wants to offer this as a gift to vice president, Xi Jinping during his visit to Hong Kong. This is unlikely, but you do have to question the timing of this offering. Why make a move that might raise eyebrows? Use common sense. Try to make it our decision instead of just yours. Again, if the government proposed this donation earlier on, when people were in more of a giving mood, perhaps they wouldn't be met with such resistance.
No comments:
Post a Comment